Struggle Well:
A Leadership Lesson for All
by Colonel Jim McDonough (U.S. Army, Retired)
S

truggle well. It is a phrase I have come to embrace more and more in life as I come to a better understanding of how best to navigate life’s challenges, particularly when failure emerges from unexpected places, at unpredicted times, in the middle of life’s pursuits. That struggle can feel all too real, almost visceral, to those stung by failure. How we respond and how we struggle through adversity is often the best litmus test by which leaders are created and then re-created from their former selves. I am a work in progress when it comes to these things, probably like a lot of others, no longer staring down at our failures themselves, but rather, beyond them and rounding the bend. Struggling well, you might say.

From a lessons-learned perspective, our response to failure can take many forms, and it often does, before we settle on a course of action geared toward overcoming the challenges that at times jolt our core beliefs and identities, the foundation upon which we have stood. I have found that amid personal struggle over failures, leadership, regardless of its application, requires brutal honesty with oneself, first to suss out its roots. This is a difficult task during trying times, those times when doubt and a lack of confidence over failure can muddle our views and cloud the reality around us.

How we respond and how we struggle through adversity is often the best litmus test by which leaders are created and then re-created from their former selves.
Hard Truths
Some refer to this as a leadership characteristic that affords you with an ability to see yourself as you are, and not how you would like others to see you. This clarity reveals genuine insight into your inner strengths and weaknesses, providing a path forward following setback and failure. It is the ultimate opportunity to set a better course, a second chance built on honest assessment and reckoning. It is also a moment in life best spent understanding the antecedents of failure, the tough things that led to being let down by others, falling and then recovering. These are the genuine moments in life when understanding becomes paramount to recovery from failure and we learn how to struggle well in its aftermath.
Leadership Is a Lifelong Journey
There are lessons to be learned everywhere, but I have discovered that the more experience I gain and the more senior I become, the more my responsibility shifts away from personal learning to sharing with others what I have learned through life’s challenges. I become more teacher than pupil, the goal being to lead others by sharing the wisdom gained through personal experience, with the hope that it affords them the opportunity for personal reflection before reaching that horrible moment when failure finds its home within them.

Time in military service is one of those rare gifts only offered to a few. For me, it was a lifetime of experience and lessons well learned that I credit with turning me into the person I am today: someone whose mistakes and failures have been overcome through resiliency, recovery and sharing setbacks, disappointment and failure with others. There were plenty of opportunities to witness tragedy, failures and personal shortcomings throughout my 26 years of active service. And like a lot of others, the learning presented through each experience provided me insight, wisdom and teachable moments through which to further develop myself and those around me. One tool in particular, the After-Action Review (AAR), became a favorite vehicle for reflecting on areas that required improvement and sustainment. The AAR has stuck with me for life as an effective vehicle for constantly assessing areas requiring additional attention, a personal tune-up following tough moments to become more self-aware and engaged with taking care of myself and others.

About Headstrong
Since its founding in 2012, Headstrong’s mission has been to heal the hidden wounds of war by providing cost-free, bureaucracy-free, stigma-free and confidential mental health treatment for active members of the armed forces, members of the National Guard and Reserves, veterans of all eras, and their spouses, regardless of discharge or combat status. With a nationwide network of experienced trauma-informed clinicians arrayed across 28 program geographies, Headstrong has emerged as a treatment practice of choice for the nation’s military-connected families by delivering advanced, individualized comprehensive mental health treatment options for those who served and their family members.

getheadstrong.org

Headstrong logo
The Leadership Path
Life in the Army was full of structure and definition. If you ever needed something, you always knew where to look for support. The further my career advanced, the more I understood the lessons behind those I considered mentors: that with command comes loneliness, and with higher levels of command that loneliness can lead to isolation. When I took the uniform of our nation off, I left at that higher level of command, somewhat alone in my journey home, an individual among individuals unfamiliar to me.

That unfamiliarity and isolation led to an ever-increasing work ethic, a form of overcompensating for something that was missing, based on the belief that I could out-work those around me through sheer determination and grit. I was the one everyone could rely on to get things done and take care of people every step of the way, just as I had been while serving in the Army. I realized that my attempts to always be superhuman led me to abruptly becoming human. This is the most important lesson I have learned to date: I am human, someone prone to failure at times.

A colleague once commented, “My god, you actually are human. What happened to you?” As I described to her my experiences with always having to be “on” all those years, I realized that in so doing I had failed those closest around me. After giving my all to those I worked with, I had nothing left to give those in my personal realm. I avoided my responsibilities. Failure, it seemed, had found me.

Personal Resiliency
What is the lesson here? We all are human and can in fact fail from time to time, but it is in how we handle that failure, how we struggle well, that we find personal recovery, resiliency and an ability to bounce back from the mistakes we make. Resiliency is one of those life concepts we read about, but it is more than a mere concept. It is borne through life’s challenges and the scars that form after we bear the burden of personal injury, whether it be moral or otherwise. In my case, the scars revealed through time’s challenges were developed at mid-life. Fortunately for me, they followed years of preparation, which allowed me to respond more successfully when called to task by failure. Insights into failure’s root causes can lead us to conclude we can learn from these moments, and that is perhaps the greatest lesson of all.
Jim McDonough headshot
Colonel Jim McDonough (U.S. Army, Retired) is the executive director of Headstrong, a leading, national-facing nonprofit providing mental health treatment for military-connected individuals and their families. McDonough completed a 26-year career as an Army officer and has held key leadership positions in both government and the nonprofit sector. He is currently pursuing his Ph.D. in law and policy from Northeastern University with an anticipated completion date of June 2022.

getheadstrong.org

LinkedInTwitterYouTubeFacebookInstagram

Colonel Jim McDonough (U.S. Army, Retired) is the executive director of Headstrong, a leading, national-facing nonprofit providing mental health treatment for military-connected individuals and their families. McDonough completed a 26-year career as an Army officer and has held key leadership positions in both government and the nonprofit sector. He is currently pursuing his Ph.D. in law and policy from Northeastern University with an anticipated completion date of June 2022.

getheadstrong.org

LinkedInTwitterYouTubeFacebookInstagram